Nationals Arm Race

Most scouts now believe that AA is the premier talent league in the minors.  AAA stores spare middle infielders and older players playing out the string while AA houses the rising talents, the up and comers that may never see the light of AAA.  Our own Jordan Zimmermann advanced straight from AA into the major league rotation.  So the AA rosters are important for the future development of the team.

Here’s what Harrisburg’s pitching staff looked like at the end of the 2010 season (age is as of 12/31/10):

• End of Season Rotation: Peacock 22, Milone 23, Thompson 23, Roark 24, Tatusko 25
• (rotation order: Thompson, Peacock, Milone, Tatusko, Roark, Peacock)
• bullpen: Kimball, Pena, RMartin, Spradlin, Dials
• spot starts:
• promotions: Storen, Strasburg, Chico, Mandel, Garate, Arneson, JJones, Carr, Bisensius
• up-and-back: Thompson, Lannan (demoted from mlb), Leatherman, Kown.
• demotions:
• dl: Meyers (would be #1), Novoa, Zinicola, CJames, JJones, Leatherman
• cut: OHernandez

Here’s the 2011 outlook for the starters in AA:

• Brad Meyers (1-0, 1.47 era, 0.98 whip, 35/7 k/bb in 30.2 innings) started out the season as the Ace of the squad and gave the team 6 strong starts before going down with injury.  He was similarly dominant at the end of 2009 for Harrisburg as well. 2010’s injury was unfortunate for Meyers in terms of career development; at 25 he’s now “old” for Harrisburg and he’s entering his 5th professional season.   I’d really like to see what he can do for this team.  2011 Prediction: starts in AA despite his proven success there in both 2009 and 2010, with an eye to quickly move up and take over for whatever AAA starters does not pan out.  With any luck he’ll earn a Sept 1 call up.
• Tom Milone (12-5, 2.85 era, 1.16 whip, 155/23 k/bb in 158 ip) had a fine season and should push for a move up to AAA.  He had nearly identical numbers in AA in 2010 as he did in Potomac the year before in terms of ERA and W/L record, but suddenly in AA he became a swing-and-miss strikeout guy.  He’s younger than Meyers and a lefty, yet has fantastic K/9 numbers and seems like a great candidate to move up in this organization.  2011 Prediction: a glut of pitchers above him and his young age seems set to start Milone in Harrisburg again, with a look to quickly move him up as with Meyers.  But his performance in AA seems to indicate he’s a rising talent, and his lefty arm doesn’t hurt.
• Aaron Thompson (4-13, 5.80 era, 1.59 whip, 95/53 k/bb in 136ip).  Thompson had an absolutely disastrous season.  He couldn’t strike guys out, he got blasted night in and night out, and it wasn’t a surprise when the Nats, facing a series of required 40-man roster moves, chose him as one of the DFA victims.  2011 Prediction: He was claimed by Pittsburgh off of waivers and is no longer in the organization. Even if he hadn’t been claimed by another team, in all likelihood he was out of the starter picture for the team.
• Tanner Roark (11-6, 3.77 era, 108/42 k/bb in 141 ip for two AA teams).  Roark pitched pretty well once he came over from Texas, but his Midland numbers were just mediocre.  He’s slightly old for the level but is only entering his 4th professional season.  I’d like to see more K/9 numbers out of him but he’s still a solid starter.  2011 Prediction: i’m predicting he moves up to AAA but he’s basically in the same boat as both Meyers and Milone; he’d be repeating a level and he may be ready to move up.  I’m predicting he moves up but will be on a short leash, targeted for replacement by either Meyers or Milone.
• Ryan Tatusko (12-3, 2.63 era, 94/53 in 136 ip for two AA teams).  Tatusko had markedly better numbers than his traded teammate.  But similarly to Roark he does not have lights out stuff.  2011 Prediction: based on his age and experience I think he gets moved up to AAA but will be in the same situation as Roark; he’ll have to perform or get moved to the bullpen.

I like both Meyers and Milone and think they’ve earned promotions.  We’ll have to see what happens in Viera.