Is Sterling Sharp getting the call? Photo unk via talknats.com
Welcome to the annual Rule 5 analysis post.
Lets take a look at who is eligible, who might get protected and make some predictions. I’ve got the Nats 40-man roster at 30 now (as of 11/6/19, after all FAs and opt outs), so there’s plenty of room to add names and do their off-season work. But, this team also needs to sign a bunch of FAs. But there’s a slew of options-challenged players who might get waived this off-season. So it’ll be an interesting Rule-5 year, and an interesting off-season in terms of roster manipulation.
As always, using the indispensable Nationals resource sites Draft tracker (at its new location, now maintained by Luke Erickson) and the Big Board, and then looking up candidate acquisitions made via trade, here’s some thoughts on who might merit protection. Also incredibly useful is Roster Resource’s Nats Roster, which keeps track of options, rule-5 status and the like.
The quick Rule-5 rules for 2019; any 4-year college-aged draftee from 2016 or before who isn’t already on the 40-man roster is Rule-5 eligible this coming off season, and any high-school aged draftee/International Free Agent from 2015 or before is newly eligible this year, assuming they were at least 18 as of June 5th of that year. There’s always a couple of guys who have specific birthdays that move them up or down one way or the other; i’ll depend on the Roster Resource rules and the Draft Tracker for exact details.
One last thing: here was our 2019 AFL Roster (also here at milb.com’s site). Often times teams put Rule-5 guys onto AFL rosters to get one last look at them against top quality performance to see if they’re worth protecting. Of course, this practice also puts a huge spotlight onto those players for opposing teams and their scouts…
- Rule 5 eligible: Sterling Sharp, Nick Banks, Andrew Lee, Jakson Reetz
- Not: Luis Garcia, Cole Freeman, Nick Raquet, Jacob Condra-Bogan, Pearson McMahon, K.J. Harrison
Newly Eligible 2016 draft College Players this year worth consideration for protection:
- Nick Banks, 2016 4th rounder LF who ascended to Harrisburg in 2019. Decent numbers and hit pretty consistently from High-A to AA this year, but he’s a corner outfielder who hit one homer in 45 AA games. You need more power than that to ascend. I mention him here b/c of draft pedigree, not because I think he’s going to be protected. I don’t think anyone could see him sticking on a MLB roster or competing with an aging ML veteran on a non-guaranteed deal.
- Armond Upshaw, 2016 11th round OF who is still in low-A; no jeopardy of getting picked.
- Jack Sundberg: 2016 26th round CF who repeated high-A for the third year in a row this season; no jeopardy of getting selected.
- Hayden Howard, 2016 12th round middle reliever who has good numbers but has never pitched above High-A ball; no real jeopardy of getting selected.
- Ryan Williamson, 2016 15th rounder who missed two full years with injury and is only in low-A; no real jeopardy of getting selected.
- Ben Braymer, 2016 18th rounder LHP starting pitcher who is one of the best draft picks (in terms of value vis-a-vis draft position) the team has had this decade. He has now risen to AAA’s rotation … where he proceeded to get shelled thsi year (7.20 ERA in 13 starts). Hard to tell if that’s the level or the PCL; i’m going to go latter since he maintained sub 3.00 ERAs at most of his stops as he ascended the minors. I think its worth protecting a home grown lefty starter who they drafted and paid a paltry $100k signing bonus for.
- Jacob Howell: 2016 21st rounder, missed all of 2018 with injury, pitched mostly in Low-A this year; no real jeopardy of getting selected.
- Sterling Sharp: 2016 22nd rounder, missed a chunk of the 2019 season with injury, but improved year over year in his AA results and then went and pitched pretty well in the AFL (6 starts, 24 innings 4 runs allowed). I think someone would take a flier on him, especially a tanking team (which now defines 1/3rd of the league). I think he should be protected.
Its worth noting that the team already has added two guys from this class who likely would have been Rule-5 this year anyway: Tres Barrera and Jake Noll both would have otherwise been on this list.
So, two candidates from this group for me in Braymer and Sharp
Newly Eligible 2015 High School-age drafted players under consideration for protection
- None
The Nats generally don’t pick HS players, so the picking here is always slim. But we’re down to just 8 players remaining in the system at all from the 2015 draft class, and none of them were HS draftees.
Zero candidates from this group.
Newly Eligible 2015 signed IFAs under consideration for protection:
- Brailin Mesa, a 2015 IFA DH who never came state-side and who probably was released after the 2017 season, but sometimes milb.com’s records are not up-to-date.
- Gerald De La Cruz: also a 2015 IFA pitcher who never came stateside and has no results past 2017: like Mesa above, probably was released after the 2017 season.
- Omar Meregildo, a 2015 IFA light hitting 3B who split time in 2019 between low- and high-A. No real jeopardy of getting selected.
- Gilberto Chu, an 2015 IFA RHP who has now appeared in short-season Auburn for 3 seasons running. Good numbers, but no real jeopardy of getting selected.
- Jhonathan German, 2015 IFA RHP closer who ascended 3 levels in 2019, ending the year in AA. Good numbers across his career, especially once he abandoned starting. I’d have a hard time believing he’d get picked though, with just 13 IP above A-ball. Perhaps we revisit his candidacy next season if he continues to pitch well in AA for a team that’s always looking for relievers.
- Felix Taveras, 2015 IFA now age 24, missed all of 2018 and threw just a handful of complex-league innings in 2019. Not getting picked.
- Tomas Alastre: 2015 IFA RHP starting pitcher who, inexplicably to me, has been a rotation mainstay in Hagerstown for two full seasons running despite his posting an ERA north of 5.00 consistently throughout that time period. Is this a case where the team is just keeping him around to eat innings? I can’t imagine that being the case with so many arms getting drafted each year. That being said, he’s only 21, so he’s still quite young even though he’s now rule-5 eligible, but he’s at no risk of getting picked in 2019’s rule-5 draft.
- Jhon Romero: 2015 IFA signing, trade bounty for Brandon Knitzler last year during the infamous purging of “bad apples.” He missed most of 2019 with injury while repeating high-A; little chance of getting selected.
Zero candidates from this group.
Rule-5 Eligible hold-overs of note: 2015 or prior college draftees still hanging out in the system, or 2014 and prior HS/IFAs.
2015 Draftees
- Rhett Wiseman, 2015 3rd round left-handed hitting OF out of Vanderbilt. Repeated High-A in 2018 and drastically improved his OPS, but it seems to be on the back of perhaps going for more of an all or nothing approach: he increased his homer output, but also struck out 122 times in 407 PAs. In 2019, he ascended to AA and hit just .215. The team invested a big bonus in him, and it hasn’t panned out. I really liked this pick at the time, but then watched him hit in the CWS that year and thought he’d have a hard time adjusting to pro pitching. So far, my amateur observation seems to be holding true. He seems likely to pass through Rule-5 once again and hit MLFA after 2020.
- Ian Sagdal, 2015 16th round senior sign who has hung around, ascending to AA for 2019 and hitting decently. He’s listed as a 1B but had just 8 homers this year; that’s not going to get him Rule-5’d.
- Andrew Lee: 2015 11th rounder basically missed all of 2017 with injury, was decent as a swingman in Low-A in 2018, then pitched pretty well in the same swing-man role, ascending to AA in 2019. Just a half a season above A-Ball; i still don’t see him as a candidate to get picked, but could turn into a James Bourque-like figure for this team next season if he continues to pitch well. He was sent to the AFL, so scouts got a look at him; is this enough to expose him?
- Tommy Peterson, 2015 12th rounder, has now missed the last two full years; he last appeared at the end of 2017. Surprised he’s still with the organization, not a candidate to get picked.
- Ryan Brinley, 2015 27th rounder, has also missed the entirety of the last two seasons with injury yet remains on the roster.
- Jorge Pantoja has bounced around the A-levels for four years now, ending last year with a 2.59 ERA in High-A … his fourth year running in Potomac. not a candidate to get picked.
- Andrew Istler, our trade bounty from the Dodgers for Ryan Madsen. He had very solid numbers in AA in a middle relief role, even earning a stellar AAA call-up. He’s an undersized Duke grad, 23rd round pick who has done well. I wonder if his pedigree makes him less likely to get picked. In 2019, he was MIA for months, finally got assigned … to High-A despite being in AAA a couple of years ago. He posted sub 1.00 ERAs in both his stops this year but is now a 27yr old RHP middle reliever. If someone didn’t pick him last year, its hard to believe he’s ever going to get picked. At age 27 with solid middle relief numbers, it isn’t out of the realm of possible though that a team could pick him and have him be their 7th man in an 8-man pen…
2014 Draftees
- Jakson Reetz, 3rd round C from 2014. Reetz was paid a big bonus out of HS, but has struggled for years. In 2019, repeating high-A for the 3rd successive year he lifted his OPS above .800 in a split-duty role, and was sent to the AFL. He only appeared in a few games in Arizona; unknown why. Its hard to see a player getting Rule-5 drafted without having never ascended above A-Ball.
- Austin Davidson started out as a corner OF and 13th rounder in 2014, now a light hitting middle infielder. Started the year in AA, demoted to high-A. Not a threat to get drafted.
- Alec Keller: a 2014 17th rounder who has ascended now to AAA, but is a high-average, low-power corner OF who seems like a classic 6-year FA AAA player who will get one more year in Fresno in 2020.
- Robbie Dickey, a 2014 4th rounder who now has no results for 3 successive years on milb.com; it seems likely that he got released after the 2017 season and the site just isn’t updated.
- Tyler Mapes, a great story who continues to hang in there. He was a 30th rounder in 2014, missed all of 2017 with injury but came back with a vengeance in 2018, dominating Potomac and holding his own with a 3.95 ERA in AA. In 2019 as a full time starter in AA he took a step back; 5.00 ERA across 26 starts, showing hit-ability and not a ton of swing and miss. He’s not likely to get picked, but is likely to stay in the rotation in 2020.
- Taylor Gushue, a 2014 Draftee out of Florida who has now made his way all the way to AAA in 2018, then hit .312 as the part-time starter in Fresno this year. I said this last year, but the lack of Catchers on the Nat’s 40-man and the fact that one of them (Raudy Read) has 63 days of service, a PED suspension and zero options seems like they should think about adding more catching depth. I’d add Gushue … but its also worth noting that despite the catching depth issues in the sport … the fact that Gushue would have to stay on a 25-man roster all year (essentially being the backup/play twice a week guy) means it’d be a huge risk to take him. More likely is that the Nats wait it out and he’s the first catcher to get added to provide cover for Kurt Suzuki and whoever else we sign this coming off-season.
- Nick Wells, our trade bounty for Austin Adams at the beginning of 2019 (bet the team wishes they had that trade back; Adams struck out 51 in 31 innings for Seattle and was a solid 7th inning guy … something we could really have used … but I digress). We got back Wells, a local kid (Battlefield HS) who for reasons unknown sat in XST for most of the summer, then got just 12 innings for Low-A Hagerstown … the same level he initially pitched in four seasons ago. I’m sure he isn’t getting picked, but I also question what the plan is for Wells at this point.
IFAs: 2014 and older
- Luis Reyes: finally made it to AA in 2018, and got shelled (12 starts, 5.18 ERA). Nonetheless the team included him in their 2018 AFL roster, where he got even more shelled (4 starts, 12 innings, 22 runs allowed). This pushed him back to Potomac for 2019, where he lost his rotation spot and struggled in middle relief. No jeopardy of getting picked.
- Joan Baez went 9-9 with a 3.79 ERA as a full time starter for Potomac in 2018, then moved into relief (finally) in 2019, where he moved up the chain and ended the year in AAA. He had good numbers in AA, not as good in AAA (but who does), but concerningly had more walks than Ks in Fresno. He’s only 24. This team is always looking for relievers. I wonder if he’s worth protecting at this point.
- Telmito Agustin, a LF who hit pretty well for High-A in 2018 (OPS of .822) … then repeated the level in 2019. Not a candidate to get picked.
- Steven Fuentes, who forced a mid-season promotion to High-A where he posted a 3.00 ERA in 45 middle-relief type innings in 2018 … and got PED suspended in 2019. Not a candidate
- Gilbert Lara, the 3B prospect the Nats received from Milwaukee in the Gio Gonzalez trade. He played all of 2018 in Low-A, then jumped up to High-A mid-2019 but is no candidate for drafting.
- Malvin Pena basically missed two full seasons, spent entirety of 2019 in High-A’s rotation and posted an ERA north of 6.00. Not a candidate to get picked.
- Aldrem Corredor, a 1B who has hung around since 2012 in the system, played 2019 in high-A as a 1b for average kind of guy; not a candidate.
- Omar Meregildo: a light hitting part time 3B who played in Potomac this year; not a candidate.
- Angel Guillen, a RHP reliever who pushed his way up to Potomac this year with solid numbers. I like him in 2020 to get to AA; not a candidate.
One solid candidate from this group (Gushue), two maybes (Baez, Istler)
MLFAs for 2019:
These are 2013 or prior college draftees, or 2012 or prior HS draftees/IFA signings.
Post-2019 publishing, i’m adding a new section because it seems like we’re going to see the following situation occur for the second time in recent memory. Long time farmhand Mario Sanchez achieved minor league free agency at the end of the 2019 season, but apparently has been re-signed (his milb.com page lists the Nationals resigning him to a contract … but its dated in the future, 12/18/19, something i’ve never seen before). But, if he’s re-signed as a MLFA with the team, then he has to be protected else he’d be subject to the draft.
This situation occurred a couple years back with Wander Suero, when the team selected his contract the day after the season ended upon his reaching MLFA status.
There’s a few other interesting newly-minted MLFA candidates who we’ve talked about in the past, but unless we have evidence the team re-signs them they’re not really candidates to discuss here. Names like Drew Ward, Jordan Mills, etc. Perhaps even Spencer Kieboom. But like Suero and Sanchez, if you want to keep them, you’ve got to sign them to a ML deal.
One candidate from this group: Sanchez
So, who would I protect?
So, remember, if someone gets drafted they have to stick on someone else’s ACTIVE, 25-man (well, now 26-man) MLB roster the entirety of 2019. So it has to be someone who could theoretically stick on a MLB roster.
- Ben Braymer
- Sterling Sharp
Who would I additionally consider?
- Taylor Gushue
- Joan Baez
- Andrew Istler
Here’s some other opinions in the Natmosphere on the same topic (i’ll add them as I see them):
- Federal Baseball thinks Sharp, maybe Braymer, maybe Istler
- TalkNats/SaoMagnifico (who’s been chatting on this post) thinks Sharp, maybe Braymer, maybe Fuentes, possibly Istler, German, Sanchez, Banks, Gushue
- BaseballAmerica.com (via Nationalsprospects.com) thinks Sharp yes, possibly Braymer, possibly Malvin Pena (??)
For a fun trip down memory lane, here’s the same Rule 5 Protection analysis post for 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015, 2014, 2013, 2012, 2011, and 2010.
By year, here’s who I predicted we’d add and who we did add.
- 2019: Predicted Braymer, Sharp. Actual: just Braymer. And…. Sharp got picked in the Rule-5 draft by Miami.
- 2018: Predicted: Bourque, Mills, Istler. Actual: just Bourque.
- 2017: Predicted: Gutierrez, Gushue, Ward, Baez. Actual: Gutierrez and Jefry Rodriguez.
- 2016: Predicted Voth, Bautista. Actual: Voth, Bautista, Marmolejos, Read and Skole.
- 2015: Predicted Kieboom, Bostick, Marmolejos-Diaz. Actual: Kieboom, Bostick, Lee
- 2014: Predicted Cole, Skole, Goodwin. Hedged on Grace, Martin and Difo. Actual: Cole, Goodwin, Difo, Grace.
- 2013: Predicted Solis as the only lock (Souza already added). Possibles mentioned in order Barrett, Taylor, Grace, Holland. Actual: Solis, Barrett, Taylor.
- 2012: Predicted Karns and McCoy, with Hood and Rosenbaum as maybes. Actual: Karns and Davis. I think we were all surprised by Davis’ inclusion, despite his good AA numbers that year.
- 2011: Predicted Norris as a lock, guessed strongly on Moore, Meyers and Komatsu. Actual: Norris, Moore, Solano, Perez. This was poor analysis on my part; I did not consider the IFAs newly eligible.
- 2010: Predicted Marrero, Meyers and Mandel. Actual: Marrero, Carr and Kimball.
- 2009: pre-dates my blog and thus no predictions, but Actual was Jaime, Thompson and Severino.
- 2008: I might be wrong, but I don’t see any evidence of the team protecting *anyone* prior to the Rule-5 draft. A bit of an indictment of the farm system at the time, I’d say 🙂
