Fedde has returned from TJ surgery successfully. Photo via chicagonow.com
Following in the footsteps of the stat review of the 2015 draft class, here’s the same analysis for the 2014 draft class, looking at their 2015 numbers and making some snap judgements.
I last did this project in 2013 (got too busy this time last fall at a new client), so this is the first time I’ve really run through the 2014 draft class in this detail. In fact, getting into the lower picks I don’t even recognize some of the names, having only really focused on the top 10 guys at the time. Its definitely interesting to see where they stand one year on.
Web links to use while reading:
- Stats are pulled from milb.com and/or fangraphs.com; put the player name into the search bar to get his seasonal stats
- The MLB Draft Tracker (which I believe is the best draft tracker out there) is the best place to get draft class information.
- The Big Board and the Draft Tracker are the goto resources for prospects for any Nats fan.
- Baseball-reference.com’s draft database
- My working XLS in Google for all this data.
Unlike the 2015 draft class analysis, we’ve already shedded a large number of 2014 draftees. And mostly we have full seasons worth of work on which to judge.
Without further ado:
Round 1: Erick Fedde RHP COL jr from UNLV. 4-1, 2.57 ERA in Short-A Auburn with 36/8 in 35ip (8 starts), 2.60 fip, .346 babip. He then got bumped up to Hagerstown where he threw another 29 innings across 6 starts with lesser stats (1-2, 4.34 ERA). A good post-Tommy John debut season for Fedde, despite the rather restrictive innings limits put on him; he was limited to just 5ip per start for a total of 64ip on the season between two levels. I’m not sure why they were so restrictive: he threw many more innings in his college career (90, 96 and then 76 before getting injured in 2014). I guess the theory was to limit him to half his pre-injury innings limit first year back, with a goal of getting back to that level of production in 2016. You Look for him to be in the Potomac rotation on perhaps a 90-100 innings limit for 2016 (or, exactly what Giolito did his 2nd year back from TJ surgery in 2014). Trending up.
Round 2: Andrew Suarez LHP COL jr from Miami (FL). Did not sign: returned to Miami for his senior year where he led his team to the CWS before getting shelled in Omaha. Drafted in the 2nd round again, slightly later than the Nats did and signed for slot for San Francisco. He did not significantly improve his draft position by playing college another year, but may have gotten more cash (we do not know what bonus amount he declined in 2014).
Round 3: Jakson Reetz, C Norris HS (NE). Slashed just .212/.326/.248 between ShortA/GCL with 37/13 k/bb in 113 Abs, 0homers 3sb just 36 games. A curious season for Reetz: why was he at short-A to begin with? He seemed to play mostly half and half time with an older DSL grad catcher and seemed outmatched in the league; why not just bring him back to Florida for another year of seasoning? Definitely a set-back year for Reetz. What do they do with him next year? Try him at Low-A after doing poorly in Short-A? Have him repeat the rookie league for the third time? Where’s the power? a .248 slugging percentage is incredibly weak. Trending Down.
Round 4: Robbie Dickey, RHP from Blinn College (TX). 0-3, 6.65 ERA starting in Hagerstown and getting demoted to Auburn. 16/17 k/bb in 23ip (6 starts). He was incredibly wild and then didn’t pitch after 7/25/15, accumulating just 23 IP on the year. Was he hurt? There was no record of a D/L trip, just an assignment back to XST after a while. All in all, a pretty disappointing season for our 4th round pick. Where does he go from here? Is the team just being too impatient with him, yanking him from Hagerstown after just a few innings? Trending Down.
Round 5: Drew Van Orden RHP COL sr from Duke. 5-5, 3.61 ERA for Hagerstown with 47/34 K/BB in 92ip (15 starts), 4.33 fip, .254 babip. Not a bad season for an under-slot senior sign, who’s clearly sticking around. He was mostly a spot starter for Hagerstown this year, getting a bunch of starts during the turmoil of the rotation. He ended the season on the DL after giving the team 92 decent innings. His FIP is a bit weak thanks to overall lucky BABIP contact but he has given no reason not to put himself into the discussion for that same role in Potomac next year. Trending Steady.
Round 6: Austen Williams RHP COL jr from Texas State. 12-8, 2.58 ERA while making the jump from Hagerstown to Potomac (with one AAA spot-start). 106/33 K/BB in 139.2 ip (25 starts). He was 8-1 for Hagerstown before getting bumped up and continued to be effective all year. Great season for Williams, putting his name on the map in the organization and starting to get some notice in the prospect rankings (he was #14 in the farm system in J.P. Schwartz‘s topprospectalert post-2015 rankings and in the upper 20s for Scout.com and MLB.com). In the mix for a AA rotation spot in 2016. Trending up.
Round 7: Dale Carey CF COL sr from Miami (FL). Slashed .234/.340/.345 for Hagerstown with 91/66 K/BB in 415ABs, 8 homers, 10/9 SB/CS playing CF. Another under-slot/cost savings senior sign who is sticking around, Carey showed some power but not great overall numbers playing CF this year. He’ll be pushed out of CF by budding uber-prospect Victor Robles unless Carey can earn a promotion, which may be hard to do. Needs to show a better hit tool if he wants to keep a job. Trending Steady.
Round 8: Jeff Gardner, LF COL sr from Louisville. Slashed .226/.296/.345 in Hagerstown with 90/38 K/BB in 403ABs, 5 homers, 8/7 SB/CS playing LF. Unlike his fellow senior sign and outfield partner Carey, Gardner is stuck in the unathletic corner and isn’t showing nearly the power or bat that he needs to stick around. He’ll get pushed out of a corner job in Hagerstown for 2016 and may lose out in a numbers game. Trending down.
Round 9: Austin Byler, 1B COL jr for Nevada (Reno). Did not sign: returned to Nevada for his senior season, led his team into the CWS playoffs and showed a ton of potential .. .but slipped out of the top10 rounds. He was the first pick of the non-bonus controlled rounds, in the 11th by Arizona, meaning his fortunes dipped slightly by staying in college another year. One last unfortunate footnote; a quick google search shows that Byler was suspended for PED-usage at the end of the 2015 season. Whoops.
Round 10: Matthew Page, RF COL sr from Oklahoma Baptist U. Slashed .270/.362/.384 between ShortA and LowA, with 54/39 K/BB in 263ABs, 2 homers, 6 sbs. Not a bad return for a $30k bonus on a college senior from a small school. He isn’t lighting the world on fire, but he’s keeping his head above water. He’ll compete with his fellow senior sign OFs Carey and Gardner for a spot in the 2016 Potomac outfield. Trending Steady.
Round 11: Weston Davis RHP Manatee HS (FL). He did not play (injured) in 2015. He had just 16 IP in all of 2014 for the GCL Nats. No word on the nature of the injury, but 16IP in two pro years is never a good start to a career. Trending down.
Round 12: Domenick Mancini RHP from Miami-Dade CC South. He was released 6/27/15; no 2015 stats after 14.2 IP in 2014. He lost out in the numbers game thanks to the massive influx of college arms competing for Short-A roster spots.
Round 13: Austin Davidson, 3B COL jr from Pepperdine. Slashed just .202/.302/.314 for Hagerstown with 47/26 K/BB in 258 Abs, 6 homers, 6/7 sb/cs playing 2B and 3B. His bat definitely took a step back in Low-A and there’s a glut of middle infielders in the 2015 class. He may not be long for the organization. Trending down.
Round 14: James Bourque RHP COL jr from Michigan. dnp – injured; no IP in 2015. He was in the Auburn rotation for 2014 and pitched adequately, but never got started in 2015. Lets hope he makes it back to compete for a job in 2016. Trending Steady.
Round 15: Ryan Ripken 1B COL soph from Indian River State (FL) Slashed .250/.296/.391 with 15/5 K/BB in 92ABs while repeating the Gulf Coast league. A curious case; why so little playing time at age 22, repeating the GCL? The team had all spring to evaluate him yet put a senior nominal slot signee (David Kerian) at 1B in Auburn instead of Ripken. Is he hurt? Is he just being rostered because of his name? Trending down.
Round 16: Cole Plouck LHP from Pima CC (AZ): went 1-0, 1.80 ERA in a 5 inning stint in Auburn… and then was released on 6/29/15. Why?? Such a strange case; why send him to Vermont if you’re going to release him a few days later? Understood if he gets lit up maybe, but it just seems odd timing. It does not look like he’s picked up elsewhere, so perhaps it was a “retirement.”
Round 17: Alec Keller CF COL sr from Princeton. Slashed .294/.341/.374 while getting promoted from LowA->HighA. 63/30 K/BB in 425 Abs, 0 homers, 11/9 Sb/cs playing CF. Not bad for a most unlikely college senior sign. If he can keep the average and OBP up and perhaps improve his SB success rate, he could put himself in a pretty good position. Trending up.
Round 18: McKenzie Mills, LHP, Sprayberry Senior HS (GA). 0-5, 7.27 ERA with 24/28 K/BB in 34.2 ip across two levels. He posted a 4.46 fip, .405 babip while in Short-A then got dropped back to the Rookie league. Rough season for Mills, who couldn’t make the jump to short-A, then struggled when back in rookie ball. Just way too many walks to be effective, but likely hangs around a bit longer since he can just hang out in XST and try to pick back up on next year’s short season squads again. Trending down.
Round 19: Clay Williamson, RF COL jr from Cal State Fullerton. Slashed .211/.318/.316 in 5 Auburn games and then was released 6/29/15 as the 2015 signees started rolling in. Never really impressed in 2014 (hitting .236 in short season) and may wish he had stayed in school instead of signing as a 19th round junior draftee.
Round 20: Bryan Langlois, RF COL jr from Pepperdine: no 2015 stats, was in XST the entire season. He had 141 mostly non-descript ABs in Auburn last year, then never got assigned this year. But, he wasn’t released either; is he injured? Converting to a new position? Trending down.
Round 21: Connor Bach, LHP COL sr from Virginia Military Institute. Posted a 6-4, 3.85 ERA with 106/69 K/BB in 110 ip (20 starts) in Low A as a member of the rotation for much of the season. 4.08 fip, .311 babip. Not too shabby for a 21st round senior sign from a relatively unknown baseball school. Perhaps too many walks, but nearly a K/inning in full-season ball portends well for his future. At the very least he could move up as a lefty specialist. Trending up.
Round 22: Daniel Salters, C COL soph from Dallas Baptist: did not sign: returned to DBU for his junior season and then was drafted by Cleveland in the 13th round of 2015 draft. He had a good 2015 short-season, so going back to school definitely helped his career.
Round 23: Chris Riopedre, SS COL jr, East Tennessee State. Went 1-4 in one game for Auburn this year and then was released on 6/25/15. He only hit .214 in Auburn last year, and the team drafted a ton of MIF players in 2015, but it does seem harsh to make the kid go all the way to Vermont just to release him after *one game*.
Round 24: Kyle Simmons RHP COL jr Texas Lutheran U. Assigned to GCL but dnp – injured and no IP in 2015. He had just a 5.03 ERA in limited innings last year in the GCL and now missed this year. As a small college junior draftee, he’ll be entering his 3rd pro season with just 19 poor innings of rookie ball performance; hard to see him making an impact. Trending down.
Round 25: Kyle Bacak C COL sr from Texas Christian U. He went 4-28 for Auburn last year and was released 1/20/15.
Round 26: Chase McDowell RHP COL 5S Rice (TX): retired 4/9/15 after putting up a 4.50 ERA in 28IP for Auburn last year. If I had to guess, he probably lost out on a full season job, was looking at sitting around in XST until June and (as an older guy, a 5th year senior) may have looked at the guys in camp who were all 4-5 years younger and called it quits. I had a friend who did exactly this: graduated a 4-year program as a highly decorated college player, then was sent to short-season ball. He got all the way to Idaho or some random place and looked at his teammates: he said they were all just as good as he was but all 3 years younger and mostly Dominican. He had a college degree, a job waiting for him and came to a quick realization that he could push for several years of below-minimum wage money looking at an uphill battle where his age worked against him, or he could just face reality and start his life. You wonder how often this really happens.
Round 27: Conor Keniry SS COL sr Wake Forest U. Slashed .250/.323/.310 while moving up from ShortA->LowA. 27/10 K/BB in 116ABs, 1hr, 3sbs as 2B. Not bad; he was clearly the backup middle infielder “guy who can play any infield position in a pinch” guy for Hagerstown. Can he stay in that role? Maybe, maybe not. He’ll have plenty of competition for that spot in 2016 thanks to a slew of 2B/SS draftees in 2015 plus rising DSL players. Trending Steady.
Round 28: Kida De La Cruz, RHP from Volunteer State CC (TN). Went 0-0, 5.43 ERA in just 1.2 IP for GCL in 2015. But he has no injuries listed. He threw 18 rather non descript innings for the GCL last year too. Perhaps they just don’t bother with D/L postings for kids on teams based out of spring training facilities since the lines seem rather blurred between “XST” and “GCL.” There were 4 or 5 guys this year who spent the entire year in “Extended Spring Training” or “To Be Determined” fashion, including a couple of very long-serving minor league arms (see the final column in the Big Board link). Either way, De La Cruz is now 21, has 20 innings in GCL with more walks than strikeouts; hard to see him making an impact. Trending down.
Round 29: DJ Jauss, RHP COL 5S from U. Mass. Amherst: was released 3/26/15 after getting hit hard in the GCL last season. Just no room for a guy who is now 25 who couldn’t cut it in the rookie league.
Round 30: Tyler Mapes RHP COL sr from Tulane U. (LA). Went 7-3, 2.23 ERA with 75/17 K/BB in 96.2 ip (8 starts) between LowA->HighA, 2.78 fip, .324 babip. Ended the year in Potomac’s rotation. What a great result set for a 30th round college senior sign. At one point he was even up in AA, though he had no appearances. Good K/BB ratio, good peripherals. Great find from the draft team. Trending up.
Round 31: Samuel Johns RHP COL 5S U. Evansville (IN). Went 3-4, 4.31 ERA between LowA and ShortA with 39/17 k/bb in 62.2 relief innings, 4.63 fip, .290 babip in lowA. He struggled in LowA, but then dropped back to ShortA and was dominant. Not great, but certainly not bad for a 31st round 5th year senior as compared to what has happened to other 5th year senior signs on this list. Maybe not the best stuff, but has been effective. My guess is that he either makes the Hagerstown team next spring or is cut loose, but the fact that he hung around this long gives him some more room to work with. Trending Steady.
The rest of the 2014 draft class was HS kids who were long shots to sign and a Juco kid in the 40th who already had a transfer agreement to a good baseball school; one more piece of evidence to perhaps shorten the draft to 35 or even 30 rounds? Here’s a quick summary.
Round 32: Cary, Elliott CF Clackamas HS (OR): did not sign: honored commitment to Oregon State.
Round 33: Casey, Clay CF DeSoto Central HS (MS): did not sign: honored commitment to Mississippi
Round 34: Skoug, Evan C Libertyville HS (IL): did not sign: honored commitment to TCU
Round 35: Doyle, Tommy RHP Flint Hill School (VA): did not sign: honored commitment to Virginia. At UVA, Doyle played an integral part in getting UVA out of the regional but did not really factor after that.
Round 36: Styles, John Henry LHP Episcopal HS (TX): did not sign: honored commitment to Stanford
Round 37: Brodey, Quinn LHP Loyola HS (CA): did not sign: honored commitment to Stanford
Round 38: Fairchild, Stuart RF Seattle Prep (WA): did not sign: honored commitment to Wake Forest
Round 39: Littell, Jon OF Stillwater HS (OK): did not sign: honored commitment to OK State
Round 40: Hill, Jacob LHP JUCO Orange Coast Coll. (CA): did not sign: transferred to U San Diego, then was drafted by Cleveland in the 32nd round of 2015 but had no 2015 innings as far as I can tell.
Trending Summary:
- Trending Up (5): Fedde, Williams, Keller, Bach, Mapes
- Trending Steady (6): Van Orden, Carey, Page, Bourque, Keniry, Johns
- Trending Down (10): Reetz, Dickey, Gardner, Davis, Davidson, Ripken, Mills, Langlois, Simmons, De La Cruz
- Did Not Sign in 2014 (12): Suarez, Byler, Salters, Cary, Casey, Skoug, Doyle, Styles, Brodey, Fairchild, Littell, Hill
- Released/Retired (7): Mancini, Plouck, Williamson, Riopedre, Bacak, McDowell, Jauss
Executive Summary
While I still think this draft was a failure for the lack of Suarez and Byler signings, we are seeing some great surprises from later picks Keller, Bach and Mapes. Reetz and Dickey under-performance hurts the class too. Fedde’s return was good, but he needs to make himself into a legit #3 starter prospect for me to start thinking more favorably about this class. However, 19 out of 40 picks either never signed or are already gone after just one year, and another 10 are trending towards a release instead of production .. this can’t be good. Lotta red in that trending summary.
PS: I created an XLS to do this analysis; if you prefer, you can see my working XLS in Google for all this data which is also listed as a link to the right (2015 Stats for 2014 Draft Class); quick XLS below:
| Round | Player/Pos | Level | 2015 Level | 2015 Basic Stats |
| 1 | Fedde, Erick RHP | COL jr | ShortA | 4-1, 2.57 ERA |
| 2 | Suarez, Andrew LHP | COL jr | did not sign: returned to Miami | |
| 3 | Reetz, Jakson C | HS | ShortA->GCL | .212/.326/.248 |
| 4 | Dickey, Robbie RHP | JUCO | LowA->ShortA | 0-3, 6.65 ERA |
| 5 | Van Orden, Drew RHP | COL sr | LowA | 5-5, 3.61 ERA |
| 6 | Williams, Austen RHP | COL jr | LowA->HighA (with 1 AAA spot start) | 12-8, 2.58 ERA |
| 7 | Carey, Dale “D.K.” CF | COL sr | LowA | .234/.340/.345 |
| 8 | Gardner, Jeff LF | COL sr | LowA | .226/.296/.345 |
| 9 | Byler, Austin 1B | COL jr | did not sign: returned to Nevada | |
| 10 | Page, Matthew RF | COL sr | ShortA->LowA | .270/.362/.384 |
| 11 | Davis, Weston RHP | HS | GCL (DL) | dnp – injured |
| 12 | Mancini, Domenick RHP | CC | released (2015) | |
| 13 | Davidson, Austin 3B | COL jr | LowA | .202/.302/.314 |
| 14 | Bourque, James RHP | COL jr | ShortA | dnp – injured |
| 15 | Ripken, Ryan 1B | COL soph | GCL | .250/.296/.391 |
| 16 | Plouck, Cole LHP | CC | released (2015) | 1-0, 1.80 ERA |
| 17 | Keller, Alec CF | COL sr | LowA->HighA | .294/.341/.374 |
| 18 | Mills, McKenzie LHP | HS | ShortA->GCL | 0-5, 7.27 ERA |
| 19 | Williamson, Clay RF | COL jr | released (2015) | .211/.318/.316 |
| 20 | Langlois, Bryan RF | COL jr | XST | no 2015 stats |
| 21 | Bach, Connor LHP | COL sr | LowA | 6-4, 3.85 ERA |
| 22 | Salters, Daniel C | COL soph | did not sign: returned to DBU | |
| 23 | Riopedre, Chris SS | COL jr | released (2015) | .250/.250/.250 |
| 24 | Simmons, Kyle RHP | COL jr | GCL (DL) | dnp – injured |
| 25 | Bacak, Kyle C | COL sr | released (2015) | |
| 26 | McDowell, Chase RHP | COL 5S | retired (2015) | |
| 27 | Keniry, Conor SS | COL sr | ShortA->LowA | .250/.323/.310 |
| 28 | De La Cruz, Kida RHP | CC | GCL | 0-0, 5.43 ERA |
| 29 | Jauss, DJ RHP | COL 5S | released (2015) | |
| 30 | Mapes, Tyler RHP | COL sr | LowA->HighA | 7-3, 2.23 ERA |
| 31 | Johns, Samuel RHP | COL 5S | ShortA->LowA | 3-4, 4.31 ERA |
| 32 | Cary, Elliott CF | HS | did not sign: Oregon State | |
| 33 | Casey, Clay CF | HS | did not sign: Mississippi | |
| 34 | Skoug, Evan C | HS | did not sign: TCU | |
| 35 | Doyle, Tommy RHP | HS | did not sign: Virginia | |
| 36 | Styles, John Henry LHP | HS | did not sign: Stanford | |
| 37 | Brodey, Quinn LHP | HS | did not sign: Stanford | |
| 38 | Fairchild, Stuart RF | HS | did not sign: Wake Forest | |
| 39 | Littell, Jon OF | HS | did not sign: OK State | |
| 40 | Hill, Jacob LHP | JUCO | did not sign: U San Diego |
