Nationals Arm Race

"… the reason you win or lose is darn near always the same – pitching.” — Earl Weaver

2026 Non-Tender Deadline Analysis

2 comments

It looks like Irvin may get a stay of execution. Photo by Jonathan Newton/The Washington Post)

November 20th is the next big day on the schedule; the Non-Tender Deadline. This is the deadline to tender contracts to arbitration-eligible players on the roster.

Interestingly, the Nat’s non-tender deadline for 2026 has mostly been neutered by all the moves they’ve already made, but for completion, here’s where we stood at the season’s end, and here’s where we stand now. I began writing this post in early November … but by the time we’re publishing it (the moment the rule5 deadline hits), most of the decisions seem to have already been made:

All 2026 Arbitration-eligible players as of the beginning of last season (in order of closest to FA):

  • Luis Garcia (Arb4): traded.
  • Cionel Perez (Arb3): released
  • Josiah Gray (Arb3): DFA’d on 11/17/26 in a Rule5 move, in a surprise.
  • CJ Abrams (Arb2): active
  • Jake Irvin (Arb2): active
  • Ken Waldichuk (Arb2): released
  • Jake Bird (Arb2): active
  • Jacob Young (Arb1): extended: 4yr/$23M plus club option of $8M for 5th year.
  • Julian Fernandez (Arb1): released
  • Mitchell Parker (Arb1): DFA’d and claimed
  • Cade Cavalli (Arb1): extended, 4yr/$47M plus club option of $25M for 5th year

So, that leaves just three (3) tender decisions. Let’s go one by one, using MLBTraderumor’s estimated salary for 2027 as a guide.


  • CJ Abrams (Arb2): $4.2M in 2026, projected $10.2M in 2027.

This is a no-brainer tender of course. Decision: tender him

  • Jake Irvin (Arb2): $2.8M in 2026, projected $3.4M in 2027.

For me this is the toughest decision for the team at this deadline. On the one hand, he’s a workhorse who’s only missed a few starts since joining the rotation several years ago. On the other hand, he’s been well below replacement level the last two seasons (both with a negative bWAR) and at age 29 … this is who he is. Is $3.4M that much for this franchise? No, not really, but tendering him also locks him into a roster spot and if this team is serious about competing in 2027 Irvin is not going to be in your rotation.

Here’s the thing though: instead of DFA’ing him on 11/17/26 to make room for the Rule-5 guys, the team kept him. Instead, they whacked Josiah Gray, who I was convinced would get another shot at the 2027 rotation. Now i’m thinking, the team views him as a healthier, better alternative to compete for the 5th spot in the 2027 rotation, and in that lens $3.4M isn’t really that bad of a price tag. So, that says to me … they’re going to tender him. Decision: tender him.

  • Jake Bird (Arb2): $975k in 2026, proj $1.3M in 2027

Bird’s usage in 2026 really confused me; for a bullpen that couldn’t keep runs off the board, he was solid in 8 appearances, then got sent down to AAA to play out the string. That must have been a bit of a bitter pill to swallow for the 30yr old with a ton of MLB time. Nonetheless, I see no reason not to tender him at a paltry $1.3M for a veteran reliever. I think he’s absolutely in that “edge of the bullpen” section that could get whacked if someone interesting pops up, but since he survived the rule-5 roster cull, he should be tendered at this cheap price. Decision: tender him.

Written by Todd Boss

November 18th, 2026 at 7:58 am

2 Responses to '2026 Non-Tender Deadline Analysis'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to '2026 Non-Tender Deadline Analysis'.

  1. Good write up, Todd. Thanks. Agree that the only remaining borderline call is Irvin.

    Just as a heads up, I tried to access the site a couple of times yesterday but it wouldn’t load.

    John C.

    19 Nov 26 at 2:05 pm

  2. FWIW, Nusbaum wrote a piece back around 11/12 that the Nats think they can add 3 MPH to get his fastball up to 95.

    “Irvin is working with team officials in West Palm Beach, Fla., to address the issue — the team hopes that if he can sit 95 mph at his frame and arm slot, he can make a significant leap. DJ Herz and Jackson Kent are among the other candidates who could compete for a spot.”

    JCA

    19 Nov 26 at 6:04 pm

Leave a Reply