Rendon’s struggles on the night led to an ending that was tough to swallow. Photo Nats Official via espn.com
As I watched the NLDS game 5 unfold, I was texting with a couple of fellow baseball fans. Here’s the content of my texts as the game unfolded for a “fun” look at my instant reactions to what was happening. I’ve only edited the texts to correct my spelling errors as I furiously typed them after two stiff drinks from my basement … everything I wrote is in blue italics.
We pick up the thread at around 10:15 pm at the bottom of the 5th.
- That pickoff was a f*cking balk. Yup, it was. You’ll note that Bryce Harper was not even looking to steal and his eyes, once Julio Urias‘ leg crossed the plane, diverted to home assuming the pitch was going home. I thought Harold Reynolds was awful announcing, but I agreed with him whole heartedly here when he said something to the effect of, “If they’re going to let him do that, he’ll pick everyone off.” What surprised me was the lack of real complaining done by either Harper or Dusty Baker there, as if they knew arguing about it was futile. In the end, it didn’t really affect the outcome of the game.
- Scherzer looks better than I ever thought he’d do. I assumed he’d give up 2 or 3 runs. After his Game 1 performance, yeah six scoreless innings was well above the expected result.
- He will run the table in the 7th then Solis for the top of the order in the 8th and then Melancon. Game is over. Ha Ha. Yeah, didn’t quite happen that way. But after he made it through the meat of the order in the top of the 6th, that was a reasonable prediction.
- Dumb play there on Werth at home; yeah, he was out by 30 feet. Post-game analysis seemed to question what Bob Henley was looking at; at the point where the relay throw was in, he was still looking out in the outfield. Is it possible that he thought the left fielder was still trying to retrieve the ball? In a meager defense of the coach, they did have Danny Espinosa coming to bat, so its not like they had a high probability of a 2-out hit based on his series batting average.
- [in response to a comment that it’s going to come down to the Nats bullpen] Except this year they’re stellar. Nats Bullpen #1 or #2 in the league in FIP and ERA and they’ve been solid this post season; just two runs in 17 innings. All true. It didn’t matter.
- Oh man homer. Finally Max makes a mistake. Except he really didn’t; look at the Pitch F/X plot of the ball Joc Pederson hit out: it was on the black and low; Pederson made a hell of a swing. It isn’t like Max grooved a belt-high gopher ball there.
- Why take him out now? Don’t like that move. Still don’t like the move yanking Scherzer; he’s on 99 pitches, he’s got 6-7-8 coming up; yes I could understand not wanting the top of the Dodger’s order to see him a fourth time, but if he already made it through all the sluggers, why not let him finish the inning?
- First batter four pitch walk; Great. I think the wrong guy is in the game. Here of course i’m talking about Mark Rzepczynski‘s not-even-close four pitch walk upon relieving Scherzer, and of course i’m saying that Dusty has brought in the wrong lefty (I wanted Sammy Solis).
- Geeze; well I guess I was wrong on the bullpen. This was after the Carlos Ruiz hit gave the Dodgers the lead.
- Every time Seager swings I think its going out he has such a powerful stroke. Its funny, but Corey Seager didn’t really have that great of a series; 3-23 but his three hits were two homers and a RBI double.
- Well that’s what happens when you don’t have a real CF. And where the f*ck was Werth backing him up? This was my reaction to Justin Turner‘s triple over Trea Turner‘s head. Initially I thought he took a bad route, but in retrospect I think that ball was just crushed. I did have a legitimate complaint about no backup though; Ruiz was running from first; could a backed up play and relay have gotten him at the plate? Maybe, maybe not.
- I think Kelley just blew out his elbow again. It did not look good when he did it … we now know he just threw so hard that he lost feeling in his hand. I’ve done that too (never on the mound, but definitely making a 100% max effort throw as an infielder, usually on a relay home). I’m glad he’s not seriously hurt.
- 6 pitchers in the inning. Crazy. Just an observation. I don’t know how long that inning took in “clock” time but it had to be over an hour.
- The guy pitching Dayton? He lived in my parent’s basement for a summer and I played with him several games back in like 2008. He didn’t throw 93 back then though. We’ve reviewed the Boss family’s personal connection to Dayton before… nothing new here.
- Lifeline!! Holy sh*t! This was of course the Chris Heisey homer. Man; Heisey’s stat-line numbers may have sucked this year, but he definitely has come up big with pinch hit homers.
- Love the move to the closer in the 7th. [on Kenley Jansen entering the game way early]: I did, and a lot of the observers of the game did too. Buck Showalter committed serious managerial malpractice for not getting Zach Britton into that do-or-die game, and now we’re seeing nearly every other manager left really thinking outside the box on closer usage. Andrew Miller‘s numbers this off-season are just off-the charts; I know he’s not the “closer” but he’s absolutely the best reliever out there, and so is Jansen for the Dodgers.
- Yeah! Great PR [pinch runner] move too by Dusty. That was putting in Joe Ross to run for Clint Robinson. I will complain about Wilmer Difo later on, but I think its worth noting that the Nats bench came up relatively big in Game 5. Heisey 2-run homer, Stephen Drew “drew” a walk (pun intended), Robinson got a hit. On the flip side, Pedro Severino flew out and both Michael Taylor and Difo struck out.
- Can’t believe Werth struck out there. Two straight un-clutch ABs. Those two “un clutch” ABs were of course Werth and then Anthony Rendon both striking out with a runner on third. Werth especially; all you have to do is hit a f*cking fly ball there and the game is tied. That’s it! Rendon’s strikeout clearly closed the book on him in Baker’s eyes.
- Good night to be an Uber driver. I think metro closed at 11:20: this was past midnight, observing that the stadium was still pretty frigging full. Steve Case had departed though; he was in the center-field camera angle all night with his front row seats.
- Huge Walk; 80% chance of a run now. How about a f*cking Espinosa bomb. This was in reference to Drew’s lead-off walk; RE of a man on first with no outs is above .8. What does Espinosa do? a bunt pop up?? From there two scrubs out quickly to end the 8th.
- Well, at least the Nats have the top of the order in the 9th. Yup; that was the silver lining; the top of the order, the best hitters on the Nats were getting a 5th shot at the title to eke out a run. If anyone could do it, it would be Turner-Harper-Werth-Murphy.
- I can NOT believe Kershaw is warming up. Enough has been written on the topic by now. But this was definitely shades of Orel Hershiser warming up in the 88 series, or Madison Bumgarner coming in for a relief outing on 2 days rest in the 2014 series.
- We’ll know soon enough he’s definitely facing Harper. I got this wrong; totally thought Kershaw would relief Jansen as soon as Turner AB was done.
- Harold Reynolds is captain obvious. I wish I could remember what he said, but it was pretty dumb. Probably something like, “If the Nats don’t score here, they’ll lose.”
- Nice inning lets see how big their b*lls are. To channel the criticism of the 2014 team as levied by San Francisco pitcher (and long time Nats tormenter) Tim Hudson.
- Katie Nolan is hot; this was my humorous comment about the Katie Nolan commercial during the pitching change in the 9th. She is hot, and she knows a ton about sports, and her podcast is pretty good.
- Why is there some idiot in a marlins jacket directly behind home plate? Again, another “killing time” text. On the TV broadcast some fool in a bright orange gaudy as hell Marlins jacket had positioned himself in pole position for the CF camera.
- Why isn’t Kershaw in? As Jansen walked Harper on four pitches. I was starting to see the narrative; “Dave Roberts holds on to his closer one batter too long” as one of the Nats middle-of-the-order guys hits a walk-off homer.
- Saving Kershaw for Murphy. Yup, it became pretty clear that was the strategy.
- Look at Kenley; he’s done. He’ll walk Werth. Yup. This was after watching a painful AB against Werth; clearly Werth was either going to drive a ball or he was going to get walked. I think Roberts let him go at least one batter too long; he threw nearly half a game of pitches. I saw a snarky post at HardBallTalk this morning “checking in with Dusty Baker,” who was quoted as saying that Jansen’s outing may affect him in the next series. Well, its a reasonable concern; he threw a TON of pitches that night. And he was gassed, perhaps before the 9th even started. Imagine the narrative if the Nats had won with Kershaw warming up and with Jansen throwing his 50th pitch?
- One day rest. Poor form booing him he’s one of the best guys in the game. Yeah, didn’t like the booing of Kershaw as he walked in.
- This is an epic match-up all things considered. Double could win it. Murphy-Kershaw. Murphy got him for 2 homers last post-season; could he at least drive in a run?
- Ugh. Worst case. Now its up to a f*cking rookie. That was it. Murphy popped up. Not a fly ball to even advance the runners. Just worst case result given the situation.
- This is 3 strikes fast. My prediction of how long it’d take for Difo to whiff.
- I bet they wish they had up Rendon right now. This, and the early hook for Scherzer, might be the two biggest second guesses I have of Baker’s moves in the game. Rendon is your #5 hitter; yes I know he struggled all series and he had badly choked earlier in the game … but why are we ending our season with a kid who struggled in AA most of the year instead of one of your most important hitters?
- Man. That sucks. Game over.
Welcome to the off-season. When I get some time, i’m going to dig into the “draft class”posts.